GUATEMALA
During
the past six months the nation has enjoyed a new climate regarding freedom of
the press. This is not to say, however, that the attacks and threats against
journalists have ceased, but at least it does not appear that there is an institutional
policy of confrontation and repression aimed at the independent media.
Nonetheless,
two recent incidents are cause for serious concern, particularly since they
involve attacks on journalists by officers with the National Civil Police (PNC).
The first and more serious of the incidents took place on August 31 during an
eviction on the Nueva Linda ranch, located in the southwestern Department of
Retalhuleu. Two journalists, Mario Morales, with Nuestro Diario, and Edward
Morales, with Guatevisión, were brutally assaulted and their respective
photographic and video cameras were seized.
Seven peasants
and four police officers died in the incident. The journalists were apparently
witnesses to illegal executions, which have been reported to the Human Rights
Prosecutor. The court with jurisdiction over the case ordered the arrest of
three officers indicated as the perpetrators. They remain in custody while maintaining
their innocence.
The second
attack was directed against a group of journalists after they had covered a
soccer match in the capital. One journalist was beaten and his camera was taken
and then destroyed by an officer when he attempted to photograph the assault.
The Human
Rights Prosecutor, Sergio Morales, has expressed his concern regarding the aggressive
stance of security forces towards journalists. The Minister of Government Affairs,
Carlos Vielman, has affirmed that he respects journalists' work and will assist
the court investigation into the Nueva Linda ranch case.
Ileana Alamilla,
director of the local news agency Cerigua, condemned the theft of computer equipment
belonging to the agency as "an act of intimidation." The equipment
contained files with important data. Alamilla is the president of the Free Press
Commission of the Journalists Association of Guatemala (APG), which has denounced
attacks and threats against colleagues.
There has
been an increase in reports of threats against journalists working on a departmental
level or in the countryside.
A bill pending
before the Guatemalan Congress to amend the Election Law and political parties
seeks to restrict or limit the use of polls for election campaigns. This constrains
freedom of the press and contravenes Article 35 of the Constitution, which holds
that no law may infringe upon the right to freedom of speech.
Although
the case is progressing slowly, formal charges were finally filed after former
Attorney General Carlos León had kept the investigation at a standstill
for more than seven months.
The Office
of the Prosecutor is now looking into a case involving an attack against the
family of José Rubén Zamora, a journalist with the newspaper elPeriódico.
A number of law enforcement personnel have been implicated in the attack. These
individuals are linked to state security forces led by high officials of the
prior administration, the Guatemalan Republican Front (FRG). Progress in the
case has been slow, although criminal charges are now pending before the courts,
following a more than seven-month suspension of the investigation by order of
former Attorney General Carlos de León.
Finally, special
mention should be made of the commendable position of administration of President
Oscar Berger toward the case of Journalist Jorge Carpio. In July 2004, the Guatemalan
government admitted its responsibility before the Inter-American Court of Human
Rights following the efforts of the IAPA, in a case that sets a precedent in
inter-American jurisprudence for the fight against impunity.