ESTADOS UNIDOS
For a second
year running, the U.S. led war on Iraq and heightened security in the country
continue to dominate press freedom issues at home and abroad. The war and counter-terrorism
related issues can broadly be divided into three areas: journalists killed in
combat, legal efforts to force reporters to reveal their sources, and US visa
regulations for foreign journalists.
REPORTERS
KILLED: By the latest count, 26 Iraqi and foreign journalists and media employees
have been killed during the Iraqi conflict, either by US troops, militia gunmen
or terrorist bombings, according to the Committee to Protect Journalists.
The Pentagon
has accepted responsibility for the deaths of two Iraqi journalists March 18
at a military roadblock in Iraq. After an investigation Pentagon officials said
the soldiers fired in self-defense, and were aiming at another car speeding
towards the roadblock.
The US later
offered "sympathy payments" to the families of the two journalists.
In April,
Assad Kadhim, a correspondent of the US-funded television station, Al-Iraqiya,
and his driver, Hussein Saleh, were killed when American forces opened fire
on their car near the central city of Samara. Camaraman Bassem Kamel was also
injured in the incident.
Following
the meeting in Chicago, the IAPA asked the Pentagon for a thorough and public
investigation into the deaths last year of four journalists in Iraq. The IAPA
also asked the Pentagon for a full explanation of its rules of engagement in
Iraq, in the interest of transparency, in order to reduce the risk of other
journalists being killed there.
The NYT
reported on Oct 24 that the Pentagon is reviewing whether to reopen an inquiry
into the case of four Iraqi journalists who said they were abused in January
at a US military base. The four were employed by foreign media organizations
working in Iraq, three for Reuters and one for NBC News. Both Reuters and NBC
have complained that the original Pentagon inquiry was inadequate. The Pentagon
has denied they were tortured.
The case
was originally dismissed by the Pentagon. But officials are reportedly considering
reopening the case in the light of abuses at the Abu Ghraib prison. The case
apparently involves abuses similar to those found at Abu Ghraib.
The four
men were arrested after trying to report on the downing of an American helicopter
near Falluja. They were held for about three days. They say that American soldiers
hit them, deprived them of sleep and made them assume painful positions. They
also said they were threatened with sexual assault and photographed while being
forced to simulate sex acts.
In regard
to CONFIDENTIAL SOURCES, an on-going federal grand jury probe into the leak
of CIA officer Valerie Plame's identity, has led to two reporters being held
in contempt of court for refusing to reveal confidential sources.
The special
prosecutor, Patrick Fitzgerald, has conducted his investigation in a disturbing
manner. He has asked several government employees, who may or may not be suspected
as sources of these alleged leaks, to sign documents releasing reporters from
any confidentiality agreements they may have made. The pressure on the employees
to sign these waivers is obvious. Worse, these unprecedented legal maneuvers
would have the ultimate effect of discouraging government employees from revealing
information important to the public on a confidential basis, because they could
not be assured the confidence would be kept.
A federal judge is pursuing the records of White House contacts with a number
of journalists. So far four have been sub-poened to testify.
The investigations
stem from the mention in a Robert Novak column of the name of CIA officer Plame,
whose husband is former ambassador Joseph C. Wilson IV, a critic of the Bush
administration's Iraq policy. Disclosure of the identity of an undercover intelligence
officer can be a federal crime, if prosecutors can show the leak was intentional.
A federal
judge in Washington DC held US reporter Judith Miller of the New York Times
in contempt of court on Oct 7 for not disclosing confidential sources to prosecutors
investigating the official leak. Miller was ordered to be held in jail until
she agrees to testify about her sources before a grand jury. She was allowed
to remain free while her lawyer appeals the judge's ruling.
The same
judge ordered Time magazine reporter Matthew Cooper jailed on Oct 13 for up
to 18 months and the magazine fined $1,000 a day for refusing to testify. His
sentence also has been suspended pending the outcome of an appeal.
Cooper had
earlier agreed to provide limited testimony to the grand jury after one of his
sources released him from a promise of confidentiality. But a special prosecutor
later issued a second, broader subpoena seeking the names of other sources.
Miller and Times Executive Editor Bill Keller have said they would not agree
to provide testimony even under those circumstances.
At least
two other reporters, from NBC and The Washington Post, have been subpoened to
testify in the same case.
In the matter
of ENTRY INTO THE US BY FOREIGN JOURNALISTS, while the number of reported incidents
has dropped, foreign journalists continue to be detained and refused entry at
US airports; this has raised concerns that the Bush administration's war on
terrorism is being used to limit foreign media access.
In a May
21 news release, US Customs and Border Protection Commissioner, Robert C Bonner,
announced that visa rules had been slightly modified. The statement said Border
Protection agents had been given discretionary authority to admitt foreign media
with visas other than the I category required of visiting journalists. Foreign
journalists will now be allowed to enter the US if they have mistakenly failed
to apply for an I visa prior to arrival. But this permission will only be granted
on a one-time basis. A journalist who benefits from this dispensation may not
be allowed to enter the country a second time without the I visa.
US Customs
and Border Protection officials insist that the detentions of foreign journalists
did not result from new orders being issued regarding the I-visa requirement.
Instead, officials said it resulted from tighter Customs monitoring since Sept
2001.
Foreign
journalists entering the US have always been required by law to obtain an I
visa. However, in the past it was customory for foreign media to be allowed
entry for up to 90 days with only a tourisit visa if they were from one of 27
countries who qualify under a 1986 Visa Waiver Program.
One final matter should be noted. The Provisional Authority in Iraq shut down
an anti-US newspaper in Iraq, that published allegations about the war which
officials said put the safety of US forces at risk.
The closure
prompted protests in the streets of Baghdad and the burning of the US flag.